I have lost my patience with Andy Carroll

Author: . Published: at 9:15am

Written by Katie Shergold @flump9

I wrote an article last month about who I would sell and keep from the West Ham squad, there were a few players on the sell list, however the player that probably produced most debate was Andy Carroll.  I have always tried to give Carroll the benefit of doubt and defended him to those that would complain about his injury record.  However, my patience has been fully put to the test and I can’t defend any more.  I want him gone from our club.

Whether you agreed that he should be sold or thought that he was too much of a valuable player to lose, after Ex’s confirmation of him being injured again and having yet more operations, I don’t think many will be able to support him much longer.  Are you not all bored of the same old story with him by now?

My reasoning behind wanting him gone from the club, is quite obviously due to his injury record and not his ability.  There is absolutely no doubting his talent, he is a quality player, a constant danger in the box, just as valuable defending in our box and on his day is unbeatable, but sadly he doesn’t often have ‘his day’.  Nevertheless, the real danger is his inability to stay fit and now his complete lack of respect towards the club!  People will argue that he doesn’t choose to be in this position and of course I agree, but at the same time, for such an injury prone player, it doesn’t appear that he is helping himself.  Andy is fortunate enough to have the privilege of being a professional football player, but his attitude appears to be letting him down.  Even if you believe there is no issue with him being out partying until the middle of the morning, surely he should be sensible enough not to pose for photographs, knowing full well that they will end up on social media and just inciting more negativity towards him.  It is just silly behaviour and I can’t imagine what goes through his mind.  I have simply lost patience with him.

The club gave permission for him to have time off and be with his family whilst recovering from his ongoing injury and he decided to go to Magaluf.  Maybe I am wrong to judge, but when you are being paid a crazily high wage and are told by your employer to have time to recover, they don’t expect to see photos of you in a club in Magaluf.  Instead of drinking until the middle of the morning, he should be working on his rehabilitation and showing his desire to get back playing for this fantastic club.  It is disrespectful towards the manager, his teammates, the board, the fans and the club as a whole.  How do the rest of the squad feel now that they are back training and he is enjoying himself partying the night away, whilst being paid 100k per week?  The club must now feel that they are being taken advantage of.

My concern is that no other club is going to take a gamble on Andy Carroll and I do not blame them.  Unfortunately, I think we missed our opportunity to sell him a few years ago and now we have no option but to allow him to continue with us or come to a mutual agreement to end his contract.  I don’t believe the second option will happen and instead I believe we will continue to pay his wages for another two years, with little reward back.

You could debate that now we have signed a proven goal scorer that the pressure will be taken away from him and instead he could be used less frequently, possibly as an impact substitute.  This option could work, but the club are paying him a lot of money for this alternative and for me it is not about his ability any more, it is his attitude.  He needs to show more professionalism and repay everyone for the faith they have shown him…….or leave.

Let me know your thoughts – @flump9 on Twitter


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Mark Beedles
    27th July 2017 at 10:18 am

    Totally agree wth your article, but i might add he should never have been brought in the first place as hus injury account at previous clubs was there for all to see

  • G Force
    27th July 2017 at 10:47 am

    I agree with your comments and have written in these pages before “Is he a liability or an asset” . The truth is he is both, but I have ,for some time now thought, that he is an expensive luxury we ought not to afford. He has had so many injuries now that I doubt he will ever be completely fit again. I also agree he shows little common sense when it comes to being photographed in these places and a lack of respect for opinion.
    In his present state he is unsaleable and I have always thought he would end up back at Newcastle ;but any club who took him would surely start with a loan to test his fitness ,which means the best we might do is lose some of the burden of his wages for a while.
    It is a pity that we are in this situation because he seems like a likeable guy and has great ability when he is fit .However,enough is enough and if he cannot get fit during this season I seriously think we should think about writing him off..